Why Arch-Support Shoes Made My Plantar Fasciitis Worse
"Arch support is good for plantar fasciitis." I believed this, bought 2 pairs of Nike arch-support running shoes, and wore them for 2 years. Result? Zero recovery.
Why I Bought Arch-Support Shoes
It seemed intuitive. The plantar fascia is in the arch of the foot, so shoes that support the arch should help, right? So I bought Nike arch-support running shoes.
YouTube said shoes were important, but there was no clear, specific recommendation. So I just went with the 'arch support' label.
What Happened Over 2 Years
From 2023 to 2024, I wore 2 pairs of Nike arch-support running shoes. It's not that they made it suddenly worse — they just kept the pain constant. No help walking, no help running. I endured the pain and kept wearing them.
I didn't realize how important shoe choice was. 'It's arch-support, so it must be good' — I didn't question it. YouTube said good shoes matter, but there was no clear recommendation of which specific model to get. So I gave up searching and kept wearing the arch-support shoes.
During this time, I was doing daily cream massage, wearing double socks, taking hospital medication — all while wearing arch-support shoes. None of it worked. Looking back, taking medicine while wearing shoes that made it worse — of course nothing improved.
Air Force 1s Hurt Less
One day I put on Nike Air Force 1s. They have a flat sole. They don't press on the arch.
My feet hurt less.
That's when it hit me: 'The arch-support shoes were the problem. I wore the wrong shoes for 2 years.' I ditched the arch shoes and switched to Air Force 1s immediately.
Why Arch-Support Makes It Worse
The plantar fascia is already inflamed. Micro-tears have been repeating, leaving it swollen and painful.
Arch-support shoes push up on the arch from below. It's like constantly pressing on an already sore spot. Every step, every stride pushes into the arch.
Same principle as when a massage ball made it worse for 2 weeks. Stimulating inflamed tissue increases pain. Arch-support shoes were doing that with every single step.
So What Shoes Should You Wear?
Based on my experience, the ranking is clear:
- New Balance 1080 — Excellent cushioning without pressing on the arch. The best.
- Nike Air Force 1 — Flat sole. Doesn't irritate the arch. Okay.
- Flat shoes in general — Better than arch-support.
- Arch-support running shoes — Avoid if you have plantar fasciitis.
Counterintuitive but true. It doesn't 'support' the arch — it 'irritates' it. If you have plantar fasciitis, avoid arch-support shoes. Don't waste 2 years like I did.
When I later switched to New Balance 1080s — the first time I put them on, I felt like flying. Cushioning that wraps your foot without pressing on the arch. Running in those shoes started the positive cycle of recovery.
This post is part of the Coupang Partners program and may earn a commission.
This is not medical advice. I'm sharing personal experience only. If your symptoms are severe, please consult a medical professional.